The Innovative Finance ISA – IFISA

Introducing the IFISA


UK taxpayers can invest up to £20,000 every year tax-free in Individual Savings Accounts – ISAs; there are a range of ISA wrappers each with different characteristics – see more here.

The Cash ISA and Stocks & Shares ISA have been around since 1999, but they have been joined by a number of new account types as the government tries to encourage us to take more personal financial responsibility; the Innovative Finance ISA (IFISA) has been around since April 2016 and as a ‘packaged’ – Do it For me – investment sits very comfortably with Muckle’s ambition to engage the next generation of investors.

The IFISA allows P2P or marketplace loans to be sheltered from tax for the first time; the sector started slowly due to the difficulty in getting regulatory approval, but there are now more than forty FCA approved providers offering the wide range of products we consider here.

Your ISA allowance of £20,000 can be invested in full in one IFISA or divided between different types of ISA up to that maximum, each giving you slightly different options.

In addition, basic-rate tax payers have a personal savings allowance (PSA) which means they can earn up t £1000 of interest tax-free; that could be from a P2P loan held outside of an IFISA.

The IFISAs we list vary greatly some are based upon property loans, others loans to small businesses and SMEs; still more combine the two.

They also vary in terms the minimum investment they will accept, and the period of your investment – typically the longer the term, the greater the reward.

As with any investment it is important that you fully understand what you are investing in, what your exposure to risk is, and what costs you will incur.

Whilst some marketplace lenders operate a lifeboat fund to cover the cost of default, not all do; your investment will be diversified over a wide range of loans, but P2P lending is a relatively new phenomenon and it is not covered by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme.

P2P loans and the IFISA do not operate precisely like other investment types and here is a brief explanation of the search parameters that Muckle applies

Transfer In

Some services allow investors to transfer in amounts of a Cash or Stocks and Shares ISA from a previous year, assuming that their provider allows transfers out; the amount must be available in cash, so for example any stocks held need to be sold first. This process is managed by the new ISA manager; an investor that withdraws cash from the previous ISA and manually deposits it to the new IFISA risks losing their allowance.

The difference to a secondary market is that with Sell-Out an investor sells all of their investments; a Sell-Out is generally conducted in order to transfer out/withdraw and exit that provider.

Flexible IFISA

If an IFISA is flexible, an investor may remove funds during the tax year without losing the allowance benefits provided the funds are put back in in time before the tax year ends.

Minimum amount

Some P2P lending marketplaces require a minimum investment amount for IFISA account; this needs to be considered if you split your allowance across ISA types.


Some IFISA offers come with a fixed interest rate but most have an interest rate range and the actual rate is dependent on the term, type, credit grade or other parameters of the individual loan.

Most rates are advertised rates and the actual achievable return will vary as it can be impacted by loan defaults, early repayments and the composition of the built loan portfolio.

Loan term

Investors will be committed for the loan term, unless the marketplace offers a secondary market or a sell-out function. However with a fully amortized loan investors can expect to have about half of the principal returned mid-term. Unlike in an 1 year ISA or 2 year ISA, investors can use IFISAs to compose a portfolio with diversified terms by investing in multiple loans.

Make sure you are comfortable with the duration of the loan you are agreeing, and the penalties you may incur should you need to access your funds before the end of the loan term.


Most P2P lending marketplaces do not charge a fee to open and maintain the IFISA account and the investments, although some do, so make sure what fees you will incur.

Secondary Market

A secondary market allows investors to sell and buy investments to and from each other and there are differences in the pricing mechanisms used.

Some only allow trading at par – the nominal price of the investment – while others allow the seller to set premiums or discounts that will fluctuate according to demand. The possibility to trade at premiums is important to those investors, that mainly want to profit from gains in their trading strategy rather than from interest earned.

Muckle’s focus is on long term wealth creation and may not dovetail with the ambitions with those with a proclivity toward trading.


The difference to a secondary market is that with Sell-Out an investor sells all of their investments; a Sell-Out is generally conducted in order to transfer out/withdraw and exit that provider.

financial education

Searching for yield? The IFISA and other opportunities

How advisors are engaging millennials and female investors in the States

Leave a Response

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Be informed as this exciting sector develops and receive DIY Investor Magazine free to your inbox – take control of your financial future